Saturday, July 24, 2010

Games or no Games, why Delhi won't change

Like the ambitious overreacher who falls flat, Delhi talks big. The more things change, the more they remain the same, writes Sunil Sethi.

Delhi, the national capital, was always a double-faced place but in the run up to the Commonwealth Games, it is acquiring a schizophrenic persona.

Poised to scale new heights as a world-class metropolis, it also appears to be falling apart. Soaring stadia with lights ablaze, swank villages for 8,000 athletes with private ice cream parlours, a metro burrowing its way to far corners and the T3, touted as the eighth largest terminal in the world. Ok, we got the message.

Why is it then that every time I enter the city, leave the house, try to catch an appointment in the suburbs or accomplish a day's jobs, I am beset with nightmarish traffic jams, long painful power cuts, waterlogged roads, (and) dangerously incomplete pavements, literally strewn with stumbling blocks?

An accurate indicator of the city's brand-new but instantly collapsing infrastructure was in the newspapers this week -- the opening of the municipality's Rs 650-crore new headquarters (grandly called a civic centre) with leaking roofs, walls soaked from seepage and a basement car park swimming in ankle-high water.

Opposition councillors caused a ruckus, brought in the press and an inquiry has been ordered.

If that's the state of the new HQ, it's no wonder that the vast municipality refuse dump at the end of my street is exactly as I have always known it -- a stinking mountain of garbage that takes days to clear.

The only new aspect to this putrefying mass is that it has now assumed the proportions of a minor Himalayan peak.

Delhi is savvy, sexy and smart -- that's if you listen to adherents such as Commonwealth Games organisers, the city's well-insulated ruling elite and its motherly chief minister Sheila Dikshit (who, every time I turn on the car radio, is exhorting children to study harder and parents to keep calm during stressful school exams or elaborating on some tree-planting drive in adverts).

Delhi is also progressive and rich -- highest per capita income amongst small states and well-above-average social and quality-of-life indicators. Day-to-day life here, however, is not what it's cracked up to be.

espite massive investment and higher levies (rates for power, water and property tax are all up) and the 70-day race to complete preparations for the Commonwealth Games, there is no evidence that Delhi's roads are less congested, electricity or water supply better managed or the Yamuna river less of a sewer than before.

Is it that Delhi can't cope with its embarrassment of riches? Sheila Dikshit has actually announced prizes -- by way of an extra month's salary -- for officials if building works are finished on time.

The city's coffers may run deep but its management is stuck in a quagmire of mismanagement and sloth.

A burgeoning metro and a fleet of low-slung, air-conditioned buses have made no appreciable difference to its clogged arteries.

Long the motor vehicle Capital of India, the city continues to add 1,000 cars a day to its streets. Privatisation of power has not reduced shortages -- outages were long and frequent through the summer months with markets covered in a miasma of generator fumes. Prices of diesel on the black market rocketed as supplies ran out.

And come the first monsoon showers, sections of the city routinely grind to a halt as roads begin to resemble rivers in spate.

Where do the funds go in one of the richest places in the country? Mostly into the pockets of the Hydra-headed government, the multiplicity of agencies assigned to the same job.

A case in point is the decades-old project to clean up the Jamuna, Delhi's main waterway. The Commonwealth Games should have been the perfect moment to restore it as the city's central showpiece, a sign of the Capital's overall prosperity and health.

Despite crores of rupees spent, noisy public campaigns, endless committees and judicial interventions, it remains a parched eyesore and repository of much of Delhi's filth.

Reason: there are 13 central and state bodies involved in its proposed transformation.
Like the ambitious overreacher who falls flat, Delhi talks big. The more things change, the more they remain the same.

Government's lapses behind hike in Games' cost: BJP

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) Saturday accused the Delhi government of mismanagement which has led to an increase in expenditure on Commonwealth Games projects.

The party also slammed the Congress-led central government for not taking all parties on board for the preparations of the Games.

Addressing reporters here Saturday, BJP national general secretary Vijay Goel said that expenditure on Games projects has been escalating ever since the first bid was made.

At the time of the first bid, the budget was Rs.1,899 crore; when it was passed by the cabinet in 2007, the budget was Rs.3,566 crore," he said.

"In March 2010, Commonwealth Games Director General V.K. Verma said the expenditure is Rs.10,000 crore, according to the sports minister it is Rs.27,000 crore and a tourism ministry report says it is Rs.87,000 crore, Goel said.

The BJP leader accused the state government of mismanagement leading to increase in expenditure on the Games.

The Manchester Commonwealth Games in 2002 cost around $14.63 million, the Melbourne Games cost around $1 billion. The 2010 Delhi Games, which are the most expensive so far, will cost around $17.5 billion, Goel said.

He blamed the Congress-led central government for not taking other parties on board for the preparation of the mega-sporting event.

The government has not discussed anything with other political parties. We want the prime Minister to take all political parties in confidence and tell us what is the status of the Games, about the preparation, he said.

He said the Delhi government is fooling people by inaugurating stadia but the construction quality of Games projects is poor.

Goel also indicated that the internal conflict within the organising committee of the Games is also the reason for the increased expenses on the projects.

Commonwealth Games Organising Committee Chairman Suresh Kalmadi and his associates were responsible for the delay, Goel added.

Over 100,000 foreign visitors are expected to throng the capital during the mega-sporting event which is to be held Oct 3-14.

Queen's Baton arrives in Nagaland

The Queen's Baton Relay for the Commonwealth Games in Delhi today arrived in Nagaland for a three-day function to be held in different parts of the state.

The baton arrived this morning at Dimapur, where a relay was held, officials said in Kohima.

Later in the afternoon, the baton relay arrived at this capital town before stopping for a photo session at Kohima Orphanage on the outskirts of the town.

The main official function will be held in Kohima tomorrow at the local ground which will be attended by chief minister Neiphiu Rio, his cabinet colleagues, government officials and prominent sportspersons from the state.

On Monday the relay will visit the historic Khonoma village before leaving for Dimapur on its onward journey to Manipur.

back to top